California Woman Sues Carnival Cruise Line After Being Struck by Towel Trolley on the Carnival Horizon
Alicia Maria Barraza, a resident of California, has filed a maritime personal injury lawsuit against Carnival Corporation in the Southern District of Florida. The lawsuit alleges that Barraza, a senior passenger using a mobility walker, suffered severe and permanent fractures after being struck from behind by a distracted crewmember operating a towel transport trolley on the Carnival Horizon on November 12, 2025.
Cruise Passenger Injured on Carnival Horizon Deck Due to Distracted Crewmember and Unsafe Trolley Operation
According to the complaint, the incident occurred on Deck 10 of the Carnival Horizon while Barraza was waiting for her family near the elevators. The lawsuit claims a Carnival crewmember operating a small trolley used for transporting clean and dirty towels collided with her from behind. The impact caused the seventy seven year old passenger to fall heavily onto her left side. The complaint states that the crewmember was severely distracted and emotionally distressed at the time of the collision due to recently receiving distressing personal news regarding a family member. Despite his compromised state of mind, Carnival allegedly permitted him to continue working and operating moving equipment in high traffic passenger areas. Barraza asserts she had no warning of the approaching cart and, due to her reliance on a walker, was especially vulnerable to an impact from behind.
Carnival Accused of Negligent Supervision and Failure to Maintain Safe Walkways for Cruise Ship Passengers
The lawsuit alleges that Carnival bears direct and vicarious liability for the unsafe conditions that led to the severe injuries. Plaintiff legal counsel argues that Carnival supervisors had ample opportunity to observe the crewmember emotional state and should have intervened by removing him from duties that required navigating heavy equipment through crowded passenger zones. The complaint references the duty of a common carrier to ensure public decks, walkways, and elevator lobbies remain safe and clear of unexpected hazards. The lawsuit contends that Carnival failed to implement or enforce adequate safety protocols that would separate moving utility carts from vulnerable passengers. The filing also points to prior similar incidents involving service carts striking passengers on other vessels, suggesting Carnival had clear notice of the recurring dangers posed by inattentive cart operation across its fleet.
Complaint Alleges Inadequate Crew Training and Failure to Warn of Dangerous Cruise Ship Conditions
In addition to negligent maintenance and supervision, the plaintiff claims Carnival failed to properly train its staff and failed to provide any warnings to guests regarding the moving equipment. The lawsuit details how crewmembers are supposed to be trained to maintain a proper lookout, control their equipment safely, and issue verbal or visual warnings when moving trolleys through common areas. The complaint argues these safety measures were entirely ignored aboard the Carnival Horizon. There were allegedly no warning signs, no cordoned off areas, and no verbal alerts given to Barraza before she was struck. The legal filing asserts that Carnival failed to account for the safety of elderly passengers who might not have the reaction time to dodge a rapidly approaching cart, making the lack of adequate warning a critical factor in the resulting accident.
Plaintiff Seeks Compensation for Permanent Pelvic Fractures and Extensive Medical Expenses Due to Maritime Negligence
Barraza brings multiple counts of negligence against the cruise line, including negligent failure to maintain, negligent failure to warn, negligent training, and negligent supervision. The lawsuit outlines that the fall caused catastrophic and permanent injuries, specifically detailing pelvic fractures, lumbar compression fractures, and a broken rib. These injuries have allegedly caused immense physical pain, emotional distress, and a profound loss of mobility and independence for the plaintiff. She seeks compensation for past and future medical expenses, hospital costs, physical therapy, required assistive devices, and damages for her ongoing pain and suffering. The complaint emphasizes that her injuries have permanently altered her daily life and diminished her overall capacity to enjoy her normal routines.
Contact a Maritime Injury Lawyer Today if You Were Hurt on a Cruise Ship Due to Crew Negligence
Cruise ship passengers who suffer injuries due to distracted crewmembers, unsafe equipment operation, or hazardous deck conditions may have the right to seek compensation under general maritime law. Cruise lines such as Carnival have a strict legal duty to ensure their staff is properly trained and supervised to prevent foreseeable harm to guests in public walkways.
If you or a family member sustained serious injuries in a similar cruise ship accident, reaching out to an experienced maritime personal injury attorney can help you navigate the complex legal landscape of federal maritime claims. Our dedicated legal team is ready to evaluate your situation, explain your legal rights, and help you pursue the justice you deserve.https://holzberglegal.com/contact-us/
Disclaimer: Our firm does not represent the plaintiff in this case and is not involved in the litigation. The information provided is a summary of allegations based on publicly available court filings. We make no representations about the truth of these allegations, are not commenting on the merits of the case, and are not predicting any outcome.











