Texas Resident Sues Carnival Cruise Line Following Fatal Medical Emergency Aboard Carnival Dream
Clayton Minnick, a resident of Texas, has filed a maritime wrongful death lawsuit against Carnival Corporation and a shipboard physician in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida. The legal action, filed under Case No. 1:26-cv-20672-RKA, alleges that Minnick’s wife, Tamreil Minnick, passed away due to gross medical mismanagement and unreasonable delays in emergency evacuation while she was a passenger aboard the Carnival Dream on February 12, 2024.
Family of Deceased Texas Passenger Alleges Carnival Dream Medical Staff Failed to Treat Acute Respiratory and Renal Failure
The complaint states that Tamreil Minnick sought urgent care at the shipboard medical center while the vessel was navigating waters near Key West, Florida. Upon arrival in a wheelchair, she reportedly exhibited clear signs of systemic illness and acute respiratory compromise. According to the filing, laboratory results obtained shortly after her arrival indicated she was suffering from life-threatening conditions, including acute renal failure and severe electrolyte imbalances that put her at immediate risk for cardiac arrest. Despite the severity of these clinical findings, the lawsuit alleges that the medical staff failed to recognize the gravity of the situation and did not provide the emergency interventions required by the prevailing standard of care for cruise ship medicine.
Lawsuit Claims Carnival Ignored Multiple Requests for Coast Guard Evacuation and Delayed Critical Medical Intubation
A central allegation in the complaint involves an extensive delay in coordinating shoreside emergency resources. Clayton Minnick asserts that he repeatedly requested that the ship’s medical team and officers contact the United States Coast Guard to facilitate an emergency evacuation for his wife. The lawsuit claims these pleas were ignored for approximately four hours. Furthermore, the plaintiff alleges that while the decedent met the clinical criteria for intubation shortly after her arrival, the medical staff waited more than two and a half hours to attempt the procedure. The complaint argues that these delays in treatment and the failure to promptly alert the Captain to the need for a ship diversion or medical evacuation directly contributed to the worsening of her condition and her subsequent death.
Carnival Accused of Misrepresenting Medical Capabilities and Failing to Utilize Face to Face Telemedicine Technology
The plaintiff alleges that Carnival markets its onboard medical facilities as high-tech centers that meet or exceed international cruise industry standards, guaranteeing passengers access to professional emergency medical attention. However, the lawsuit claims that in this instance, the cruise line failed to utilize available Face to Face Telemedicine tools that would have allowed for real-time consultation with shoreside specialists in Miami. The complaint further suggests that Carnival failed to adequately staff the vessel with enough qualified personnel to manage a critical care emergency. By holding the medical staff out as cruise line employees through their uniforms, officer status, and integrated billing systems, the plaintiff argues that Carnival is vicariously liable for the substandard care provided by the shipboard doctor and nurses.
Legal Team Cites Previous Medical Negligence Cases Against Carnival to Establish Knowledge of Inadequate Shipboard Care
To support the claim that Carnival had knowledge of potential deficiencies in its medical operations, the complaint references several prior lawsuits filed in the Southern District of Florida. Cases such as Murphy v. Carnival Corp., Gharfeh v. Carnival Corp., and Rinker v. Carnival Corp. are cited as evidence that the cruise line was aware of past incidents where shipboard physicians allegedly provided improper medical advice or treatment. The plaintiff contends that despite these prior occurrences, Carnival failed to implement the necessary policies, procedures, and communication tools required to prevent similar tragedies. The lawsuit seeks damages for pre-death pain and suffering, mental anguish for the surviving family, and the loss of consortium and financial support resulting from the decedent’s passing.
Contact a Cruise Ship Medical Malpractice Lawyer if a Loved One Suffered Due to Delayed Evacuation or Improper Care
If you or a family member experienced a medical emergency on a cruise ship that was worsened by a lack of proper treatment, a failure to evacuate, or a delay in ship diversion, you may have grounds for a maritime tort claim. Cruise lines are required to provide reasonable care under the circumstances and must ensure their medical staff is equipped to handle foreseeable emergencies. If a cruise line’s negligence resulted in a permanent injury or wrongful death, it is essential to consult with a legal professional who understands the complexities of maritime law and the specific statutes of limitations that apply to the cruise industry.
Contact us now to speak with a cruise ship slip and fall attorney.
Disclaimer: Our firm does not represent the plaintiff in this case and is not involved in the litigation. The information provided is a summary of allegations based on publicly available court filings. We make no representations about the truth of these allegations, are not commenting on the merits of the case, and are not predicting any outcome.
