Texas Woman Sues Carnival Cruise Line After Chair Collapses During Event Aboard Carnival Jubilee
Charlotte Foy, a resident of Texas, has filed a maritime personal injury lawsuit against Carnival Corporation in the Southern District of Florida. The lawsuit, filed under Case No. 1:26-cv-24712-JEM, alleges that Foy suffered serious and permanent injuries after a wooden chair she was sitting in suddenly broke and collapsed while she was attending an onboard seminar aboard the Carnival Jubilee on June 9, 2025.
Cruise Passenger Injured Aboard Carnival Jubilee Due to Defective Lounge Seating with No Warnings
According to the complaint, the incident occurred during the morning hours while Foy was a fare-paying passenger aboard the vessel, which had recently departed from Galveston, Texas. Foy was seated in a wooden chair provided by Carnival in the Limelight Room, an interior passenger lounge, seminar room, and event space located on Deck 7. While she was attending a Diamond Exchange seminar, the chair suddenly failed with a loud cracking sound, completely crumbling beneath her. The sudden structural failure jolted Foy, threw her entirely off balance, and forced her to abruptly jump up as the furniture failed. Crew members immediately removed the broken chair from the venue following the incident. Foy asserts that the chair was in a structurally unsound, defective, and unreasonably hazardous condition that was not open, obvious, or visible to her prior to the collapse, leaving her with no reason to anticipate the risk.
Carnival Accused of Failing to Inspect, Maintain, and Remove Hazardous Passenger Furniture Across Fleet
The lawsuit alleges that Carnival had both actual and constructive knowledge that passenger seating aboard its vessels could become defective, deteriorated, and unstable if not properly managed. Plaintiff’s legal team references a long history of prior slip, fall, and collapse lawsuits filed in the Southern District of Florida involving identical furniture failures aboard various Carnival ships. The complaint cites multiple specific historical cases offered as evidence of fleet-wide notice, including Adams v. Carnival Corp. aboard the Carnival Sensation, Walter v. Carnival Corp. aboard the Carnival Legend, Brady v. Carnival Corporation and Keith Irons v. Carnival Corp. both involving the Carnival Vista, Tesoriero v. Carnival Corp. aboard the Carnival Splendor, Lachindia Brown v. Carnival Corp. aboard the Carnival Liberty, and Lamont Pitts v. Carnival Corp., which involved an identical chair collapse in the Limelight Lounge aboard the Carnival Breeze. Despite this extensive history of passenger injuries from failing seats, the cruise line allegedly failed to perform reasonable inspections or enforce adequate safety protocols to discover and remove the hazardous chair before allowing passengers to sit.
Complaint Alleges Negligent Failure to Warn and Lack of Proper Safety Protocols in Carnival Jubilee Event Spaces
In addition to failing to maintain its shipboard furnishings, Foy alleges that Carnival breached its legal duties by failing to provide any warnings to passengers regarding the structural integrity of the venue seating. The complaint argues that Carnival failed to post warning signs, notices, cones, or barricades, and failed to advise passengers attending the seminar that the seating was unstable or unfit for use. Because Carnival is responsible for setting up and arranging the chairs prior to shipboard events, the plaintiff argues the cruise line should have discovered the defect through routine maintenance, repair records, or pre-event inspections. Despite knowing that uninspected furniture posed a foreseeable risk of structural failure, the cruise line did not restrict access to the defective seating or warn passengers that identical furniture had caused severe injuries to cruise guests in the past.
Plaintiff Seeks Compensatory Damages for Left Knee and Hip Injuries, Medical Expenses, and Lost Value of Cruise Vacation
Foy brings counts of negligence against Carnival, including negligent failure to warn and general negligence. She claims Carnival breached its maritime duty of reasonable care under the circumstances to maintain its common areas, equipment, and furnishings in a reasonably safe condition for fare-paying passengers. The lawsuit states that as a direct and proximate result of the chair collapse, Foy sustained severe and life-changing bodily injuries to her left knee and left hip. Her injuries have required extensive medical treatment and will necessitate ongoing future medical care, including surgery. She seeks compensation for physical pain, suffering, mental anguish, disability, disfigurement, lost earnings, diminished future earning capacity, and the lost value of her cruise vacation, asserting that her losses are permanent and continuing in nature.
Contact a Cruise Ship Furniture Collapse Lawyer Today if You Were Hurt Aboard a Vessel in Unsafe Conditions
Cruise passengers injured by broken furniture, defective seating, or unmaintained amenities in shipboard lounges and event spaces may be entitled to compensation under maritime law. Cruise lines like Carnival have a strict legal obligation to ensure that the chairs, equipment, and public areas provided to passengers are thoroughly inspected, properly maintained, and entirely safe for passenger use. If you or someone you care about was injured in a similar shipboard seating accident or furniture collapse, contact our team of experienced maritime injury lawyers today. We are here to help you understand your legal rights and explore your options for recovery.
Contact us now to speak with a maritime attorney.
Disclaimer: Our firm does not represent the plaintiff in this case and is not involved in the litigation. The information provided is a summary of allegations based on publicly available court filings. We make no representations about the truth of these allegations, are not commenting on the merits of the case, and are not predicting any outcome.
